Sent: Wednesday, September 05, 2007 6:29 PM
Subject: Balloon Accidents
Hi Marcie, I just ran across your website today and have read all the comments. I am saddened by the severe injuries you and Susan Wedge received and I deeply regret that this pathetic Sprague individual has found ways to harm so many folks both physically and financially. I fully agree with what the professional commercial hot air balloon pilots have shared although the sarcastic tone of one was not called for. But beyond that, there was a quote by Ms. Wedge that was not justified and I certainly did not care for it: "We all share your passion in spreading the word as to how truly unsafe & unpredictable hot air ballooning is."
As already indicated by several of your e-mails, all of us do not share these passions and as it has already been clearly and professionally stated, it is not the form of transportation that is unsafe, it is the operator. But in Ms. Wedges defense, if I had received her injuries, I might have unthoughtedly said something much worse. I wish that those of you that have been harmed could all join forces and direct your energies towards the main cause of your pain and suffering and that seems to be for the most part, the individual by the name of Steve C. Sprague. He should be shut down and not the form of transportation he chose to profit by.
Mr. Sprague seems to be the one with the primary guilt here but from what I have read, the Federal Aviation Administration also shares in the guilt. I think that any who read this would agree that bureaucracies, businesses, churches, families, etc. all have some bad apples here and there. Having an FAA accident investigator only asking Mr. Sprague about the accident is like having the fox guard the hen house. How absurd! I have dealt with some fine, upstanding, professional FAA personnel and I have dealt with a few total jerks that worked for this agency. Seems the latter description fits the one who "inspected" this accident and also the one who was later asked about the accident. Looks to me like these individuals knew little about the applicable Federal Aviation Regulations (FAR's). If these bimbos (well, they acted like bimbos) had followed the FAR's and done their job in a rightful manner, Mr. Sprague may not have had the opportunity to expose others to his unprofessional ways for at least a period of time.
Perhaps a few of you who may read this might be wondering about along now what my background is. I am a 66 year old retired commercial hot air balloon pilot, husband, father of two, and grandfather of six. I hold the first commercial hot air balloon pilot's certificate issued in Georgia (1972) and was the co-builder and co-owner of the first hot air balloon registered in the state. I have flown balloons in four countries and 34 states and when I retired from ballooning along about 1985, I had logged over 1500 hours which is far less than the 5000 hours of one of the comment contributors but I flew professionally for a much shorter time. I am also a fixed winged pilot and have flown sail planes and a Benson Gyrocopter. I was the number one ranking balloon pilot in the nation for a short period in 1978 and came in 2nd place in the 1978 Hot Air Balloon National Championship that same year and I flew in the World Hot Air Balloon Championship in Sweden in 1979. I was called in by the FAA on two occasions for questioning basically because the inspectors knew little about balloons and perhaps knew even less about some specific FAR's. After amicable discussions, no charges were filed. I must also share that I found the FAA officials to be very helpful concerning matters pertaining to Supplemental Type Certificates (STC's), operational waivers, etc. Although the "F" stands for Federal, I did run into situations where different geographical offices seemed to have their own interpretations of some of the FAR's which made things difficult as I flew in so many different states. And oh yes, I was a hot air balloon accident investigator for the Balloon Federation of America in the 80's. Marcie and Susan, surely God spared your life for a purpose. If you don't know what it is, try to find out! Our lives are our gift from God. What we do with our lives are our gift to God!
There is another problem concerning the overall subject at hand that has not been mentioned in these postings. I have felt over the years that ballooning has been treated by the FAA to a degree like a bastard child. Balloon pilots have been required to operate by FAR's written for powered aircraft. Also, as both a balloon pilot and an airplane pilot, I feel that there are times when it takes more judgment to fly a hot air balloon than it does an airplane. Yet, the FAA requires less training for a balloon pilot to obtain a commercial rating than it does for a commercial fixed wing pilot rating. In my opinion, I feel it is too easy for someone to purchase a balloon, rush through a sometimes less than adequate training program and before really being qualified, they are flying passengers for hire in a "unpredictable" aircraft....and yes, some balloons are unsafe for various reasons such as a pilot in his haste to fly, unknowingly purchases an unairworthy balloon and flies it before getting it properly inspected. One of the contributors of these postings said she paid $12k for a ragged out balloon. I know the story, in ones excitement to have one of these "huge, colorful, enchanting, attention getting objects", they throw caution and common sense out the window while they might be more prone to take a used car to a reputable garage for inspection before purchase. Buyer be aware should certainly be applied to an aircraft purchase.
This has already been basically stated but I'll close by saying we see people injured, maimed, or killed in cars, boats, jet skis, snowmobiles, motorcycles, trains, airplanes, buses, etc, etc, etc, and we do not launch campaigns against these modes of transportation, so why pick on hot air balloons? Pick on the bad drivers, the bad boat captains, operating any vehicle under the influence and especially pick on bad hot air balloon pilots. Yes, balloons are unpredictable, that is one of the beauties of ballooning. Society is so programmed to get from point A to point B in a certain amount of time. In a balloon, you don't know (exactly) where you are going and you don't know (exactly) when you are going to get there. But this IS predictable, hit live wires in a balloon and you probably can't say you have had a good day. Do remember that the balloon envelope did not get out of its bag by itself!!!!
H. Harold Carter